Комментарий практики рассмотрения экономических споров (судебно-арбитражной практики). Выпуск 27. Коллектив авторов

Скачать книгу

в том случае, если предмет залога был реализован по такой высокой цене, которая не только позволила удовлетворить текущие требования, реестровые требования первой и второй очереди, но и полностью погасить задолженность перед залоговым кредитором. В таком случае оставшиеся денежные средства подлежат распределению между иными реестровыми кредиторами, что в свою очередь подтверждает заинтересованность последних в наиболее выгодной реализации предмета залога.

      6

      См.: постановление Арбитражного суда Западно-Сибирского округа от 07.06.2018 по делу № А27-395/2015.

      7

      См.: Постановление Арбитражного суда Поволожского округа от 05.03.2020 № Ф06-30493/2018.

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

Скачать книгу