“I doubt it.” Gideon shrugged. “Maybe if you knew what it was called.”
“Probably not worth the time it takes to sort it out.” She slid it into one of the contractor-strength trash bags they’d found upstairs. “This bag is about full. What do you think I should do with it?”
Looking around at the mountain of things they’d be throwing away, Gideon decided. “I’ll hire a roll-away Dumpster. We’ll probably generate a lot of debris through the construction process, so we might as well have one on-site.”
Once the Dumpster arrived, Gideon was surprised with how quickly they began to fill it. Though he felt encouraged by the progress they were making clearing out the basement, with every bag of trash they hefted outside, he was left with fewer possible clues. Nothing he saw seemed suspicious. He began to wonder if the killer might have had time to remove whatever it was before Gideon had arrived and discovered Glen Arnold’s body.
As Maggie toted another bag outside, Gideon’s eyes roved over the room. Nothing looked suspicious to him. Doubts taunted him. Was he pursuing an empty lead? No. Between Glen’s final words and the certainty in his gut, he knew there had to be something in that basement. And his instincts had always served him well as sheriff.
“Gideon?” The breathless way Maggie spoke his name from the doorway sent a shot of fear through him. When he wheeled around, the stark-white frightened expression on her face sent his adrenaline racing into overdrive.
“What is it?”
“I think the killer may have returned.”
FOUR
Maggie tried to remain calm as she led Gideon back outside to show him what she’d found. If whoever had killed her father really was watching them, she didn’t want to give them the satisfaction of seeing how much their actions had disturbed her.
“What is it?” Gideon asked again as they stepped outside.
“I’ve been tossing the trash into this end of the Dumpster,” Maggie explained in the calmest voice she could muster. “I’m too short to see inside it from the ground, but I was thinking after all the bags we’ve thrown in there, surely they ought to reach the top by now.”
She didn’t have to say any more. Gideon leaped up the metal-bar ladder that was welded to the side of the roll-away. His groan told her he’d seen the same thing she had.
He looked down at his hands and groaned again. “I suppose I just wiped out any fingerprints they might have left.”
“I’m sure they were all gone after I touched it.” She tried not to think about what she’d seen inside the Dumpster—the bags carefully untied, the contents sorted out, as though someone had been going through everything they’d thrown out. They may have even been inside the roll-away as she’d thrown in more bags, but she hadn’t seen them because of the high metal sides.
But what made her want to scream in fear were the words scrawled along the back inside wall of the Dumpster.
GIVE IT BACK
The jagged block letters made Maggie feel threatened.
“What do they want?” she asked.
“Something from the basement?” Gideon suggested. “It looks like they were searching through the things we threw out.”
“But don’t you think—” Maggie tried to suppress a shudder, but failed “—don’t you think it looks like some things are missing?”
To her relief, Gideon took her question seriously and looked back into the roll-away. “You’re right. That bag was full of all those broken vacuum attachments and that old wrapping paper that was falling apart, but I don’t see half the vacuum attachments anymore. And I think some bottles are missing from that bag over there.”
Maggie could picture the bag he was talking about. It had been dragged to the far end of the Dumpster and all its contents had been emptied out. She knew some of it was either missing or hidden among the other bags. Her gut instinct told her it had been taken. But why?
With a wordless prayer, she looked up to the clear-blue Iowa sky as though God might send her answers straight out of heaven. Instead she saw a broken gutter hanging down from the eaves, and felt that much more disheartened by the project she’d undertaken—which she’d never asked for in the first place. Pushing away her discouragement, she asked Gideon the question that was foremost in her mind.
“Do you think we missed it—the suspicious thing my dad told you about? Do you think his murderer took it with them?” Her voice dropped off as she returned her gaze to the roll-away Dumpster and then back to Gideon.
For a moment she thought the suspended lawman was about to agree with her. But then his features hardened and he shook his head.
“No. It has to still be inside. This only makes me all the more certain.”
“Why?”
“Because if your father’s killer had what they were looking for, they wouldn’t be asking for it back, would they?”
It took three days to empty out the room in the basement. Most of what they hauled out went straight into the roll-away Dumpster, and remained undisturbed after their discovery. Checking inside the Dumpster with every load had guaranteed that, though Gideon had hoped whoever had scrawled the message would come back so they could catch him. Not that there was much chance of that.
They both agreed that, given Bernie’s accusations about his missing Taser, they wouldn’t bother the sheriff’s office about the message, but instead took pictures as evidence.
A few things they found fell into the category of curiosities, and those Maggie took to the local antiques shop for appraisal. But nothing they found fit into the suspicious, you’re-not-going-to-believe-this-until-you-see-it category. Certainly none of it seemed like anything worth killing someone for.
After checking the Dumpster one last time and finding it clear of invaders, Gideon tossed the last contractor-strength garbage bag into the container with a mighty shove, then turned to face Maggie. “Basement—check,” he announced, feeling satisfied that they’d cleared out the debris. Only a few large furniture pieces remained, and those they’d agreed to keep with the possibility of using them to partially furnish the house.
When he met Maggie’s eyes, Gideon felt his feeling of satisfaction take a hit. That worried look was back, and she’d crossed her arms over her chest as she looked around the overgrown backyard.
He hurried to her side. “I’m sorry we didn’t find what we were looking for.”
Though Gideon knew she was disappointed, Maggie put on a brave face. “It’s okay. We tried. We still have the rest of the house to go through.”
“True.” Gideon wished he could make his voice sound optimistic. The gutted second floor was wide-open space, with only Glen Arnold’s tools and stacks of wood lying around. The attic was a smallish space, and didn’t have room for much under its shallow rafters. The first floor was a little more promising, as Glen had hardly disturbed it yet. But Gideon seemed to recall Glen had made his suspicious discovery in the basement. And their pokey perpetrator’s
