Jews & the Japanese. Ben-Ami Shillony

       To

       Lena, Iris, and Ruthy

      Contents

       PREFACE 9

       PART ONE: Shared and Singular Traits

      1 Chosen Peoples and Promised Lands 15

      2 Affirmation of Life and Centrality of Nation 26

      3 Security Lost and Security Assured 34

      4 The Perpetuity of Emperors and Priests 39

      5 Two Peoples of the Book 45

       PART TWO: The Successful Outsiders

      6 Seclusion and Explosion 53

      7 Master or Genius? 62

      8 The Rejection of Christianity 70

      9 Anti-Semitism and Anti-Japanism 75

      10 Salvation by Emigration 82

      11 From Auschwitz to Hiroshima 91

      12 Lessons of War and Postwar Miracles 96

      13 Jew Baiting and Japan Bashing 104

       PART THREE: Connections and Relations

      14 The Jews and the Beginning of Modern Japan 111

      15 The Legend of the Ten Lost Tribes of Israel 134

      16 The Jewish Role in the Russo-Japanese War 143

      17 Japan Supports Zionism after World War I 151

      18 Zionism Stirs Messianic Hopes in Japan 158

      19 The Rise of Japanese Anti-Semitism 164

      20 The Abstract Jewish Demon 171

      21 Japan Saves Jews in World War II 178

      22 Jewish Scientists and the Atomic Bomb 190

      23 Jews in the Allied Occupation of Japan 194

      24 Israel and Japan: A Developing Relationship 201

      25 Japanese Attraction to Israel and Judaism 208

      26 A New Wave of Japanese Anti-Semitism? 216

      27 Prospects for the Future 223

       REFERENCES 227

       INDEX 237

      PHOTOGRAPHS (on pages 113-128)

      Preface

      IT IS DIFFICULT to imagine two more widely different—almost incompatible—societies than those of the Jews and the Japanese: a people spread over the four corners of the world versus a people with an almost uninterrupted history of sovereignty in its own land; geographical heterogeneity versus linguistic and cultural homogeneity; a cosmopolitan experience versus an island mentality; strict religious and moral commandments versus group-based and aesthetically bound values. Yet, there are also surprising analogies between these two peoples. It is this extraordinary combination of similarities and differences that I would like to explore in this book.

      The Jews and the Japanese are just two of the many interesting and unique peoples who inhabit this earth, two that are not ordinarily associated with each other. Yet over the last two centuries these two peoples have surprised the world, both by what they have done and by what has been done to them. Their outstanding achievements and immense tragedies, their enthusiastic attempts at integration into the Western world and their repeated rejections by it, their epochal transformations in the nineteenth century and again after World War II, and their present dilemmas of survival and direction—all these are significant stories with strong common elements that need to be studied and analyzed.

      The purpose of this book is to compare the rich cultural heritages and historical experiences of the Japanese and the Jews from early times to the present and to see how these have influenced the behavior of each group. The book then looks at the ways these "successful outsiders" have interacted with the Christian West as well as with each other throughout the stormy course of their modern histories.

      As a Jew, an Israeli, and a longtime student of Japan, I thought it was my duty to tackle this subject, to connect the several worlds in which I live. A comparative study of the Jews and the Japanese may also help us to better understand both. The basic differences and the outstanding similarities can provide us with a new perspective on the religions, traditions, values, and modes of behavior of these two peoples.

      Many friends and colleagues have helped me along the way in this undertaking. Nicholas Ingleton, the president of Charles E. Tuttle Company, and Barbara Brackett, the U.S. and international marketing director, were excited about the idea before they had seen even one written word of the manuscript. The Harry S. Truman Research Institute for the Advancement of Peace of the Hebrew University of Jerusalem, of which I had the honor to be chairman, provided me with the means to write this book and was considerate enough to tolerate my long absences while I was doing so. R. J. Zwi Werblowsky, Peter A. Berton, and David G. Goodman read parts of the manuscript and contributed thoughtful remarks. Frank Joseph Shulman provided me with important bibliographical and biographical data. Albeit A. Altman, Hans H. Baerwald, David Kranzler, Gerhard Krebs, Muramatsu Takeshi, Miyazawa Masanori, and Maruyama Naoki shared with me, over the years, some of the valuable information that they had acquired through personal experience and academic research. Harry Wall and Willy Stern were helpful in providing various reports and newspaper clippings, and my students David Oberman and Roberto Chait searched the libraries to find additional information. Emily Biederman made valuable remarks concerning content and style, and the Tuttle editorial staff added the finishing touches.