Arguments Within English Marxism. Perry Anderson
Чтение книги онлайн.
Читать онлайн книгу Arguments Within English Marxism - Perry Anderson страница 1
![Arguments Within English Marxism - Perry Anderson Arguments Within English Marxism - Perry Anderson](/cover_pre681807.jpg)
The characteristic form taken by English Marxism since the war has been study of history. No writer exemplifies its achievements better than Edward Thompson, whose Making of the English Working Class is probably the most influential single work of historical scholarship by a socialist today. An editor of The New Reasoner in 1957-1959, a founder of the New Left in 1960, now an eloquent champion of civil rights, Thompson has most recently aroused widespread interest with the appearance of his Poverty of Theory, which combines philosophical and political polemic with Louis Althusser, and powerful advocacy of the historian’s craft. Arguments Within English Marxism is an assessment of its central theses that relates them to Thompson’s major historical writings themselves. Thus the role of human agency—the part of conscious choice and active will—in history is discussed through consideration of its treatment in The Making of the English Working Class. The problems of base and superstructure in historical materialism, and of affiliation to values in the past, are reviewed in the light of Whigs and Hunters. The claims of utopian imagination are illustrated from the findings of William Morris. Questions of socialist strategy are broached in part through the articles now collected in Writing by Candlelight. Exploring at once differences and convergences between New Left Review and one of its founders, the essay concludes by suggesting the virtues of diversity within a common socialist culture.
Perry Anderson
Verso
British Library
Cataloguing in Publication Data
Anderson, Perry
Arguments Within English Marxism.
1. Thompson, Edward Palmer
I. Title
907′ .2′024 D15.T5/
© Perry Anderson, 1980
Verso
UK: 6 Meard Street, London W1F 0EG
US: 20 Jay Street, Suite 1010, Brooklyn, NY 11201
ISBN-13: 978-0-8609-1727-4 (PB)
ISBN-13: 978-1-78478-793-6 (US EBK)
ISBN-13: 9781-7-8478-792-9 (UK EBK)
Contents
1.Historiography
2.Agency
3.Marxism
4.Stalinism
5.Internationalism
6.Utopias
7.Strategies
Bibliography
Index
The historian may tend to be a bit too generous because a historian has to learn to attend and listen to very disparate groups of people and try and understand their value-systems and their consciousness. Obviously in a very committed situation you can’t always afford that kind of generosity. But if you afford it too little then you are impelled into the kind of sectarian position in which you are repeatedly making errors of judgement in your relations with other people. We have seen a lot of that recently. Historical consciousness ought to assist one to understand the possibilities of transformation and the possibilities within people.
EDWARD THOMPSON
Edward Thompson is our finest socialist writer today—certainly in England, possibly in Europe. Readers of The Making of the English Working Class, or indeed Whigs and Hunters, will always remember these as major works of literature. The wonderful variety of timbre and rhythm commanded by Thompson’s writing at the height of its powers—alternately passionate and playful, caustic and delicate, colloquial and decorous—has no peer on the Left. Arguably, too, the strictly historical achievement of the series of studies that extends across the 19th and 18th centuries from William Morris to the rich group of recent essays whose collection is promised in Customs in Common is perhaps the most original product of the corpus of English Marxist historiography to which so many gifted scholars have contributed. Setting aside any other consideration, it is rare for any researcher to become equally at home in two such contrasted epochs. Whatever comparative estimate is made in this respect—where doubtless no final judgement is attainable—two distinctive characteristics of Thompson’s practice as a historian stand out. Throughout, his has been the most declared political history of any of his generation. Every major, and nearly every minor, work he has written concludes with an avowed and direct reflection on its lessons for socialists of his own time. William Morris closes with a discussion of ‘moral realism’; The Making of the English Working Class recalls our debt to the ‘liberty tree’ planted by the early English proletariat; Whigs and Hunters ends with a general revaluation of the ‘rule of law’; an essay like ‘Time, Work-Discipline and Industrial Capitalism’1 speculates on the possible synthesis of ‘old and new time-senses’ in a communist society of the future that has surpassed the ‘problem of leisure’. Each of these texts has been in its own way a militant intervention in the present, as well as a professional recovery of the past. The massive consistency of their direction, from the mid 50s to the late 70s, visibly attested in the long Postscript to the new edition of the study of Morris (1977) is profoundly impressive. At the same time, these works of history have also been deliberate and focused contributions to theory: no other Marxist historian has taken such pains to confront and explore, without insinuation or circumlocution, difficult conceptual questions in the pursuit of their research. The definitions of ‘class’ and ‘class consciousness’ in The Making of the English Working Class; the critique of ‘base and superstructure’ through the prism of law in Whigs and Hunters; the reinstatement as disciplined imagination of ‘utopianism’ in the new edition of William Morris—all these represent theoretical arguments that are not mere enclaves within the respective historical discourses, but form rather their natural culmination and resolution.
The claim on our critical respect and gratitude, then, is one of formidable magnitude and complexity. Some appraisal of Thompson’s central ideas and concerns is, however, long overdue. The publication of The Poverty of Theory provides an occasion to begin such an assessment.2 Released over a year ago, it has received a generally favourable press in England. But at the date of writing, no extended response to it has so far appeared. Given the challenge of the book, this seems like something of an anti-climax. In many ways, I cannot be regarded as the most apposite interlocutor. The Poverty of Theory contains four essays, three already published and one unpublished. The former include the famous critique of views of English society and history developed in New Left Review, entitled ‘The Peculiarities of the English’, to which I rejoined over a decade ago. The latter is an attack across two hundred pages on the thought of Louis Althusser, and by its scale and novelty inevitably dominates the book. The appropriate respondent to it would obviously be an Althusserian. However, in the absence for the moment of more indicated candidates, it