face, but the wave of guilt that followed kept him silent.
“That was the worst moment of my life.” John continued to stare at him. “I loved LeeAnn. If things had turned out different, she would have been my wife.”
Mick was surprised. Being Tucker Rivendale’s parole officer, he’d known that Tucker loved LeeAnn and she returned the feeling. As far as he knew, they’d been exclusive since LeeAnn returned to Silver Creek. Never had he even heard John Bender’s name mentioned. He shot a look at Keeley, but she didn’t meet his eye.
He’d missed something. Again.
You didn’t know a lot of things, Mick. If you had, LeeAnn wouldn’t be dead.
* * *
In the following hour, three cops handled the investigation, interviewing them. Keeley sat calmly on the still-clean sofa, John holding her hand.
Something about the gangly man annoyed Mick, but then, holing up on his family’s raptor sanctuary since he quit his job hadn’t given him a lot of practice getting along with people. John Bender, as Mick soon figured out, was an avian veterinarian. LeeAnn had worked as his part-time receptionist. Mick remembered LeeAnn mentioned something about studying to become a vet someday.
Mick sat quietly, listening to every detail until the chief, a short, stocky man by the name of Uttley, finished up.
“Roadblocks are set up and we’ve got people coming from the area response team to help with a door-to-door search.”
“He can easily stay in the woods,” Mick said.
The chief raised an eyebrow and patted his front pocket until he found a butterscotch candy, which he stuck in his cheek. “How you figure?”
“He was a big camper back in the day. Almost an Eagle Scout before he started getting into trouble. Loved the survivalist stuff.”
The chief sucked, mouth working as he took in Mick’s information. “Think he’ll stick around?”
Mick nodded and looked at Keeley. “He said something to you, didn’t he? What was it?”
She started. “I can’t remember. It all happened so fast.”
“Are you sure?” he pressed.
“Yes.”
“I heard him speak to you.”
John looped an arm around her shoulders. “She said no, didn’t she?”
Keeley looked at the floor. “I’m really tired and I have to get up early.”
“I’m going to have a patrol car drive by throughout the night, just as a precaution.” The chief excused himself. “Staying in town, Mr. Hudson?”
Mick could see by the chief’s sharp eyes that he was nobody’s fool. It made him feel better. A little. “Not sure. Maybe I’ll drive back home tonight.”
Home? Was that what he had at the sanctuary? A home? It had begun to feel more and more like a hiding place. When he was ten he’d taken a dare and left school at lunchtime, climbing to the top of a fire lookout in the woods. His grandpa Phil had found him that day and took him right back to school, where he’d been made to write an apology to the teacher and sit with the first graders at lunchtime for a week. He’d towered over those kids, trying without success to scrunch down so he wouldn’t be as obvious as Gulliver in the land of the Lilliputians.
“You can’t hide from shame, Micky boy,” his grandpa had said.
No, you can’t, Grandpa.
When there was nothing left to say, Mick accepted a ride from Uttley back to his truck, parked a half mile from where he’d finally caught up with Keeley and Tucker.
Uttley was quiet for most of the trip, but Mick knew his wheels were turning.
“Got a call from Reggie Donaldson alerting us that Rivendale was likely on his way. Not time enough for us to do much.”
Mick watched the moon glittering in brilliant streaks through the spires of the fir trees.
“So I get that this is personal.” He cleared his throat. “I’ve been here awhile, so I was on the team that found LeeAnn. I wasn’t the chief then. We were dispatched after Keeley got the text from her sister. I replay it in my mind all the time. I think if we’d found her sooner, if we got there quicker, we could have taken him into custody. More bad luck that your pal Reggie spotted him and tried to make the arrest. Tucker took him down, the car rolled into the pond, and he was long gone before we made it on scene.” He huffed out a breath. “I had a bad feeling when we pulled that car out of the water, but I hoped it wasn’t true. Kept right on hoping until we popped the trunk.”
Reggie had told Mick later that the sight of LeeAnn in that trunk would never leave his memory to his dying day. “It was as if she was staring at me, asking how we let it happen.”
How had Mick let it happen? How had he been so completely fooled about Tucker’s character?
Uttley shook his head. “Poor kid. LeeAnn was only guilty of loving the wrong guy. Never understood how girls could be so led by their hearts and not their heads.”
Mick kept quiet.
Uttley tapped the steering wheel. “I’ve had situations that went bad, too. It stays with you. I understand. I know what it’s like to believe in a parolee, to want them to succeed so much it blinds you to the facts.”
There was something naked and raw in his tone that spoke of personal experience, but Mick knew cops, and they didn’t share with people who didn’t wear badges. Mick waited for the bottom line.
“But you’re not a cop, and you make things worse by being here, so I’m glad you’re going home.”
Mick knew Uttley was right. Go home. Stay out of it. It will only make things harder for the family I’ve already ruined.
Still, he wondered as he thanked Uttley and gunned the engine on his truck.
What had Tucker said to Keeley back there in the darkness?
And why had she chosen not to tell the police about it?
* * *
I want what’s mine. Had Tucker really said it? Did he really know? She’d not heard correctly. That was all. Her mind played a vile trick on her.
Keeley could not dislodge the words from inside.
Jaw tight, she finally convinced John to leave.
“I’m fine. The house is locked up. The police are increasing their patrols. I’ll be at the vet clinic tomorrow evening to help with the birds for a couple of hours.”
“Keeley, it’s okay to admit you’re scared. Why don’t you take some time off? Let me cook for you, or we can go for a walk.”
She shook her head. “Thank you, but I need to work.” Did she ever. The tiny house
