Maps as descriptions
Maps as spaces for commensuration
Maps as instruments of power
Second-degree objectivity
Controversy atlases
Narration and exploration
Datascape navigation
9 Mapmaking as a form of intervention
Hybrid forums and parliaments of things
Controversy mapping as an open-air experiment
Data sprints
Critical proximity
11 Controversy mapping in the shadow of Gaia The end of Nature Learning from Penelope
12 A conversation with Bruno Latour “A mix or maybe a mess of ideas” “Every philosophy of science concept is in fact a simplification of a data structure” “The word controversy has always been controversial” “We believed we would have Tarde, and we got fake news” “The temporal aspect of fact making” “Here is a new task for controversy mapping”
13 References
14 Index
Guide
1 Cover
7 Preface: The politics of association on display by Richard Rogers
10 Controversy mapping in the shadow of Gaia
11 A conversation with Bruno Latour
12 References
13 Index
List of Illustrations
1 Preface: The politics of association on display by Richard RogersFigure 0 Mapping the online mentions of rare minerals
2 IntroductionFigure 1 Tree of disagreements around the conservation of Amboseli elephantsFigure 2 Actor/issue table of the Amboseli controversyFigure 3 Network of actors in the Amboseli controversyFigure 4 Debate scales and scale inversion in the Amboseli controversyFigure 5 Stream diagram of the temporal evolution of the Amboseli controversy
3 Chapter 1Figure 6 Map of how three different indexes of vulnerability disagree in assessing countr…Figure 7 Bilateral adaptation funding and vulnerability indexingFigure 8 Controversy mappers accused of spying on wind turbine opponentsFigure 9 Four criteria for estimating the feasibility of a controversy mapping projectFigure 10 The hype cycle of controversy mapping
4 Chapter 2Figure 11 First attempt at inventorying the issues surrounding the plans for developing th…Figure 12 1934 map of Southern Copenhagen circulated by the developer as part of the debat…Figure 13 Map of the area where the development is planned showing the concentration of un…Figure 14 Map demonstrating that the construction site is on the site of the old landfillFigure 15 Two of the photos showing how in 2001 the meadows were almost completely strippe…Figure 16 Map of the area showing the location of the red-listed species and the planned d…
5 Chapter 3Figure 17 Screenshot of a post on the Friends of the Common Facebook group with the three …Figure 18 Artistic rendition of the proposed artificial island “Nordhaleøen”Figure 19 Area chart showing the shifting prevalence of different issues in the Friends of…Figure 20 “Angry” and “love” reactions to posts and comments in the Friends of the Common…Figure 21 Facebook posts from the Friends of the Common group, and from the pages for the …Figure 22 Banksy, Love Is in The Air, Flower Thrower, 2005
6 Chapter 4Figure 23 Elements of a terroir, as told by Jean-Marie around his vineyards in BerlouFigure 24 Extract from the official map of the Languedoc AOCsFigure 25 Trained vines with irrigation system on the plains near Béziers and troll vines on…Figure 26 Cellar floor, fermentation tanks, and the dog named Terroir in Béziers; cellar f…Figure 27 A semiotic triangle of French wine oppositionsFigure
