it did arise in this connection.’
‘Has he mentioned it more recently?’
‘I ventured to bring it up a fortnight ago when he consulted me about renewing the lease of his house. He replied, as I thought, rather oddly.’
‘What did he say?’
Mr Benningden swung his umbrella out in front of him as though he were pointing it at his own statement.
‘He used, as far as I can recollect, these very words: “It’s no go, Benny; I’ve been caught poaching and I’ve lost my licence.” I asked him what he meant by that, and he laughed, very bitterly I thought, and said that marriage with a woman who understood you was emotional suicide, a phrase that had the advantage of sounding well and meaning nothing.’
‘Was that all?’
‘I pressed him a little further,’ said Mr Benningden uncomfortably, ‘and he said that he had made an enemy of a woman who still loved him, and added something about grand-opera passions and his own preference for musical comedy. He seemed very sour and, I thought, almost alarmed.
‘The subject was dropped, and we did not refer to it again until he was leaving. I remember as he shook hands with me he said, “Goodbye, Benny. Control your curiosity. I may promise to reform, but it’ll be the death of me if I do”.’
Mr Benningden stopped short and stared at Nigel.
‘He said this quite gaily and irresponsibly,’ he added. ‘It has only just occurred to me how strangely it may sound now that he is dead. Ah, well, it’s of no consequence, I dare say.’
‘Probably not,’ agreed Nigel abstractedly. ‘There are the gates, Benny. Let me know if there is anything I can do.’
‘Yes, yes, of course. I am meeting Detective-Inspector Alleyn at the police station. He is a very able man, Nigel. I feel sure your cousin’s death will not go unavenged.’
‘I am afraid,’ said Nigel, ‘that in this respect I too have little of the grand-opera instinct. My one hope is that Charles was not murdered by any of his friends. That old butler, the Russian—why don’t the police do something about him?’
‘I feel sure they are doing quite a lot in that direction,’ rejoined Mr Benningden drily. ‘Goodbye, my dear fellow. I shall be down for the inquest, of course. In the meantime, goodbye.’
Nigel walked slowly back towards the house. The prospect of spending the rest of the afternoon indoors was not an attractive one. The house-party lived on with a horrible posthumous individuality. The grotesque nature of their enforced familiarity was beginning to tell on the nerves of all the guests. Nigel was conscious of strange and hideous suspicions working like a ferment in their minds. Frantock had become envenomed. He longed to get away from it, and with this idea at the back of his head, turned off the drive and walked down a side path towards the wood. He had not gone far when a bend in the path revealed a green bench and sitting on it, curiously huddled, the figure of Rosamund Grant.
Nigel had seen very little of her since the tragedy. As soon as the official inspection of their rooms was over, Angela and Doctor Young had taken her upstairs, and there she had stayed, as far as Nigel knew, ever since. She raised her head now and caught sight of him. Feeling that he could not turn back, and conscious of the horrible restraint that came between himself and all of them, he walked up to her and made some conventional inquiry about her health.
‘Better?’ she said in her deep voice with its falling inflexion. ‘Oh, yes, I’m better, thank you. I shall be joining your jolly party downstairs in time for the inquest on your cousin’s murder.’
‘Don’t!’ said Nigel.
She flung herself back impatiently.
‘Have I dropped a brick?’ she said. ‘Do you cut the murder dead among yourselves? Angela and I talk about it, or rather Angela talks and I listen. She is a peculiar person, Angela.’
Nigel did not answer. She stared at him fixedly.
‘Of what are you thinking?’ she asked. ‘Are you wondering if I killed him?’
‘We all wonder that about each other, all day and half the night,’ said Nigel brutally.
‘I don’t.’
‘You are the more fortunate.’
‘I only wonder what that man Alleyn is doing, what he is building up out of the mass of detail, what neat, ugly conclusion he is coming to. They say the Yard is never wrong in its inferences, though it sometimes fails to get its results. Do you believe this?’
‘My only information is based on detective fiction,’ said Nigel.
‘So is mine.’ Rosamund laughed silently, shrugging up her thin shoulders. ‘And nowadays they make their Yard men so naturalistic that they are quite incredible. This man Alleyn, with his distinguished presence and his cultured voice and what-not, is in the Edwardian manner. He hectors me with such haute noblesse it is quite an honour to be tortured. Oh God, oh God, I wish Charles were not dead!’
Nigel was silent, and after a moment she began to speak again.
‘A week ago,’ she said, ‘no, three days ago—I thought to myself, quite seriously, you know, that I should be glad if I knew I was going to die. Now—now I am terrified.’
‘What do you mean?’ Nigel broke out, and at once checked himself. ‘No—don’t tell me without being sure you won’t wish that you hadn’t.’
‘I’ll tell you this much,’ she said; ‘it is not the detective that I am afraid of.’
‘Then why don’t you go to him and make a clean breast of whatever it is?’
‘What! Betray myself!’
‘I don’t understand you,’ said Nigel heavily. ‘Why can’t you tell Alleyn what you did when you went upstairs? Nothing can be more dangerous than your silence.’
‘Suppose I said I went in search of Charles?’
‘That? For what reason?’
‘Someone is coming,’ she said quickly.
There was indeed the sound of a light footstep beyond the trees. Rosamund stood up as round the bend in the path came Marjorie Wilde.
She was wearing a black overcoat, but had no hat on. When she saw them she stopped dead.
‘Oh—hullo,’ she said. ‘I didn’t know you two were out here. Are you better, Rosamund?’
‘Yes, thank you,’ answered Rosamund, staring at her. A heavy silence fell among them. Mrs Wilde suddenly asked Nigel for a cigarette.
‘We have been having a cosy chat about the murder,’ said Rosamund. ‘Who do you think did it?’
Mrs Wilde laid her hand to her cheek, and her lips parted, showing a line of clenched teeth. Her voice usually so shrill, came at last on an indrawn breath.
‘I can’t
