Greek and Aramaic spreading at the expense of all the minority languages. Although Aramaic was a language closely related to Phoenician or Hebrew, Greek had still been taken up by a large part of the Jewish community (especially those in Egypt) in this period. Greek had also become a basic subject in the education of Romans, who were by the second century BC clearly recognised as the rising power.
The cultural undertow was thus running strongly in favour of Greek. And in fact it is possible that, despite its users’ commercial prowess, Phoenician or Punic had never been widely used as a lingua franca or even as a trade jargon outside Africa. The language of trade is, after all, perforce that of the customer, rather than that of the merchant.
The Roman comedian Plautus illustrates this in a scene from his play Poenulus, ‘the Punic guy’—‘Punk’?—which came out in the early second century BC, soon after the end of the Second Punic War.43 A Carthaginian merchant tries talking to a couple of Romans in Punic, even though he knows Latin, but soon tires of their constant heavy puns and jokes on him and his language, to cloak the poor language skills of the one who claims to be a bit of Punic expert. (Hanno’s Punic is in bold, and the Latin that echoes it is in bold italics.)
HANNO: mechar bocca MILPHIO: Istuc tibi sit potius quam mihi.
AGORASTOCLES: quid ait? MILPHIO : miseram esse praedicat buccam sibi. fortasse medicos nos esse arbitrarier.
AGORASTOCLES : si ita est nega esse; nolo ego errare hospitem.
MILPHIO: audin tu? HANNO: rufe ynny cho is sam
AGORASTOCLES: sic volo profecto vera cuncta huic expedirier. roga numquid opu’ sit. MILPHIO: tu qui sonam non habes, quid in hanc venistis urbem aut quid quaeritis?
HANNO: muphursa AGORASTOCLES: quid ait?
HANNO: mi uulech ianna
AGORASTOCLES: quid venit?
MILPHIO: non audis? mures Africanos praedicat in pompam ludis dare se velle aedilibus.
HANNO: Good morning to you. MILPHIO: Better you than me.
AGORASTOCLES: What is he saying? MILPHIO: He says his jaw hurts.
Perhaps he thinks we are doctors.
AGORASTOCLES: Then say we’re not; as a stranger, I don’t want him misled.
MILPHIO: Are you listening? HANNO: Doctor, no one is perfect.
AGORASTOCLES : Yes, I certainly want all this explained to me.
Ask him if he needs anything. MILPHIO: You without a belt, why have you people come to this city, or what are you after?
HANNO: What do you mean? AGORASTOCLES: What is he saying?
HANNO: What is he on about to a stranger?
AGORASTOCLES: Why has he come?
MILPHIO: Don’t you hear? African mice [a joke for ‘elephants’?] he says he wants to present to the city wardens for the circus parade.44
Still, the fact that the Punic dialogue is in there at all suggests that a smattering of Punic was not strange to Romans at the time, and good for a laugh.
The Carthaginian army (largely made up of mercenaries from all over the western Mediterranean) is said to have been commanded in Greek; certainly the coins struck by the soldiers during the great mutiny in 241–238 BC, the so-called ‘Truceless War’, were inscribed in Greek. And it is known that the annalists who accompanied Hannibal on campaign in Italy, Silenos and Sosylos, wrote in Greek. When Hannibal put up a plaque recording his exploits in a temple of Hera in Sicily, it was in Greek as well as Punic.45
The Phoenicians and Carthaginians, notorious as shrewd businessmen, must have been pragmatists; like their modern analogues, they would have focused on the practical utility of a means of communication, and chosen a language accordingly. In the last couple of centuries BC, it was clear that the most generally useful international language in the Mediterranean was Greek.
In Carthage itself, and the North African provinces of Libya (to the east) and Numidia (to the west), Punic did continue to be used. But there is no evidence of Punic literary activity after the Roman conquest (146 BC). Literacy seems to have become restricted to the use of Latin and Greek. The Punic cultural traditions ceased to be fostered, and the physical record of this once highly literate society did not last much longer.
The universal medium for administrative and literary records had been papyrus, a material that survives long-term only in extremely dry conditions (such as those of the Egyptian desert). Texts that were not inscribed on a durable medium such as stone, ivory or clay would not survive unless they were repeatedly copied—a service that was maintained for seminal texts in Greek and Latin, and indeed Hebrew, throughout late antiquity and the Middle Ages, until the printing press made them safe. There was no tradition to preserve Phoenician or Punic texts, and so they perished with the papyrus on which they had been written.
As for the spoken dialects, they will most likely have survived until succeeded by larger-scale neighbouring languages. Interestingly, in both cases, these new languages were Semitic, closely related to Canaanite dialects and in fact rather similar to them. Phoenician in the Lebanon will have yielded to Aramaic in the first century BC; and the last remnants of Punic in North Africa probably succumbed to Arabic in the seventh or even eighth century AD.*
Aramaic—the desert song: Interlingua of western Asia
In the fourteenth year of King Hezekiah’s reign, Sennacherib king of Assyria attacked all the fortified cities of Judah and captured them. Then he sent his field commander with a large army from Lachish to King Hezekiah at Jerusalem... The field commander said to [Eliakim, Shebna and Joah, Hezekiah’s emissaries]:
This is what the great king, the king of Assyria says: on what are you basing this confidence of yours?... Yahweh himself told me to march against this country and destroy it.
Then Eliakim, Shebna and Joah said to the field commander, Please speak to us in Aramaic [‘arāmīth], sir, since we understand it. Don’t speak to us in Hebrew [y∂hūdīth] in the hearing of the people on the wall.
But the commander replied:
Was it only to your master and you that my master sent me to say these things, and not to the men sitting on the wall—who like you will have to eat their own shit and drink their own piss?
Then the commander stood and called out in Hebrew:
Hear the words of the great king, the king of Assyria! This is what the king says: do not let Hezekiah deceive you. He cannot deliver you!...
Isaiah xxxvi.1–14 (= 2 Kings xviii.17–29)
These events, which took place in 701 BC, show that at this stage Aramaic, although the
