examples.
Years, decades, centuries pass by before somebody comes up with this or that idea. Great inventors have to sort out thousands of options before coming to the right solution.
Thomas Edison had failed 2,000 experiments before he succeeded in improving a light bulb filament.
In order to invent the alkaline battery, he had to perform some 50,000 attempts. Edison himself was optimistic and didn’t consider these attempts as a failure, but rather as discovering 50,000 ways that wouldn’t work.
Companies, agencies, people waste enormous intellectual and time resources.
It is sad, but in the 21st century, people keep doing the same. They sort through countless variations before they find the right one. The main way to create new ideas is still the great-grandfather’s method of trial and error.
Several years ago, one Russian nationwide newspaper asked its young readers: “Which methods of solving creative problems do you know?” Here is what a seventh-grader from Bashkiria answered: “The method of solving a creative problem is a man sitting with a thoughtful face, looking at the ceiling and scratching his forehead”. I would not say that this picture differs from the real situation even at quite serious and respected companies.
Advertising is a business of ideas.
Every day creative agencies are committed to coming up with many concepts for clients. How does it happen in practice? Take a look at the graphic record of the process of finding a solution at one of the advertising boutiques (see Fig. 1.).
Drawn by Juriy Gerasimov
Fig. 1. How the ideas of the adman work in the 21st century.
As you see, the same good old trial-and-error method is the queen of the ball. However, sometimes brainstorming1 is used as one of its variations.
It is extremely inefficient. Companies, agencies, people waste enormous intellectual and time resources. Here is the working process of an ad team described by a person who knows about it firsthand.
As an employee in an agency creative department, you will spend most of your time with your feet up on a desk working on an ad. Across the desk, also with his feet up, will be your partner—in my case, an art director. And he will want to talk about something like… movies. In fact, talking frankly, you will spend a large part of your career with your feet up talking about movies.
The ad is due in two days. The media space has been bought and paid for. The pressure’s growing. And, meanwhile, your muse is sleeping off like a drunk behind a dumpster or twitching in a ditch somewhere. Your pen lies useless.
That’s when the traffic person comes by. They’ll come by to remind you of the horrid things that usually happen to snail-assed creative people who don’t come through with the goods on time.
So you try to get your pen moving. And you begin to work. And working, in this business, means staring at your partner’s shoes. That’s what I’ve been doing from nine to five for over 20 years. Staring at the bottom of the disgusting tennis shoes on the feet of my partner, parked on the desk across from my disgusting tennis shoes. This is the sum and substance of life at an agency. 2
In this book we will consider an alternative approach to the search for innovative ideas in advertising. Here, perhaps for the first time in epochs of advertising history there appear creative techniques that allow you to get a strong solution without sorting multiple options. These methods are discussed in detail and are analyzed and combined into a system.
The same good old trial-and-error method is the queen of the ball in the advertising industry.
Knowledge and skillful use of these techniques will dramatically increase the creative potential of people working in design and advertising. At the same time, those psychological barriers that hinder finding sharp advertising solutions are discussed and analyzed.
Chapter 1
The tool borrowed from physics
“Two things are infinite: the
universe and human stupidity;
and I am not sure about
the universe.”
Albert Einstein,
Theoretical physicist
Once, travelling on a train, I met a young man who supplied the equipment for medical institutions of the Karelia region of Russia. We had a chat. When he heard that I was creating ideas for advertising, he asked if there are special technologies in our profession.
My answer was: “If the advertiser did their homework conscientiously and studied deeply the product or service, the creative ideas show up by themselves”.
He was delighted with these words. He had attended various training sessions many times and so many times he’d heard from western and domestic gurus the profound maxim: “Be creative!” But no one had ever at least tried to explain how to be creative. It turns out that it’s simple. It is necessary to explore the advertised product inside out.
This is simple but not easy. Every day you need to gather information, pick up interesting facts, and search for numbers. It is hard, tedious, painstaking work.
But when I answered the question of my fellow traveler, I did not say everything. Special creative techniques do exist, and ad people use them.
The Polish physicist Leopold Infeld in his autobiographical writings mentions the problem that the young Peter Kapitsa once suggested to him and Lev Landau. With a serious face Kapitsa, who worked at that time in Cambridge with Rutherford, voiced this problem:
“A tin can is tied to the tail of the dog. When the dog runs, the can keeps knocking on the pavement. Question: how fast should the dog run to avoid hearing the noise of the can?”
Infeld and Landau thought for a long time.
“Do you give up?” Kapitsa asked.
“We do” the physicists admitted reluctantly.
The other scientist looked at them with a smile and gave the answer: “The speed is zero.”
What complicates the solution of such a simple task?
In the case about the dog’s tail, the speed is mentioned in its conditions. In our mind, speed is inextricably linked with movement.
In this problem, we unintentionally consider only the options that imply movement. Of course, even children are aware that a speed may be equal to zero. But it is not typical. We are so used to this idea of speed meaning movement that we veer far away from the correct answer.
That is why, in the physical sciences, an efficient and powerful method is often used. That is: go to the consideration of the limiting case3. The same method can be successfully applied in advertising.
Let’s imagine that we need to advertise a super-fast sports car. It
