IFG International Forum on Globalization
IFIs international financial institutions
IMF International Monetary Fund
ISI import substitution industrialisation
LAT labour aristocracy thesis
LRC Legal Resources Centre
MEC minerals–energy complex
MST The Landless Peasants’ Movement
NATO North Atlantic Treaty Organisation
NCEUS National Commission for Enterprises in the Unorganised Sector
NDP National Development Plan
NDR National Democratic Revolution
NEP New Economic Policies
NGO non-governmental organisation
NUM National Union of Mineworkers
Numsa National Union of Metalworkers of South Africa
OECD Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development
OWS Occupy Wall Street
PAH Mortgage Victims Platform
PALMS Post-Apartheid Labour Market Survey
PASOK Panhellenic Socialist Movement
PBF Bolsa Família
PRC Rifondazione Comunista (Communist Party, Italy)
PRIA Participatory Research in Asia
PSDB Partido da Social Democracia Brasileira
PT Workers’ Party
QES Quarterly Employment Survey
RBI Reserve Bank of India
RosaLux Rosa Luxemburg Foundation
SACP South African Communist Party
SAHRC South African Human Rights Commission
SBTC skill-biased technological change
SDS Students for a Democratic Society
SGP Stability and Growth Pact
SER standard employment relationship
SERI Socio-Economic Rights Institute of South Africa
SOEs state-owned enterprises
SV Socialist Left Party
TAC Treatment Action Campaign
TAPGs Transnational Alternative Policy Groups
TNI Transnational Institute
TTIP Transatlantic Trade and Investment Partnership
UDF United Democratic Front
UK United Kingdom
UN United Nations
US United States
USSR Soviet Union
WSF World Social Forum
WTO World Trade Organization
INTRODUCTION
Vishwas Satgar
Until recently, the Great Depression of the 1930s was considered the worst crisis of capitalism. Today, historians, economists and the business media have confirmed that we are now experiencing the worst crisis of contemporary capitalism. The early-twentieth-century Great Depression seems to pale in comparison to the ‘great financial crisis’ that occurred at the beginning of the twenty-first century. Despite the massive bailouts given to banks and finance houses, deepening austerity in the heartlands of capitalism and a tenuous continuity in growth rates in countries like China and India, the end of the crisis is not in sight. This, of course, does not mean capitalism is about to collapse – but it is certainly in a state of deepening crisis and will probably reach a historical terminus, like all social systems before it.
However, this volume does not attempt to make catastrophic predictions, but instead sets out to explain and provide an understanding of the unfolding crisis by bringing into view its underlying dynamics.
With such a deep systemic and conjunctural crisis facing neoliberal capitalism, both in South Africa and beyond, one would intuitively expect the Left to be on the rise and gaining ground. Yet there seems to be an unevenness regarding effective left-wing responses to the crisis. In most instances, trade unions, social movements and left-wing parties seem to be advancing responses that are incapable of bridging the gulf between the current realities and popular expectations of progressive transformation, such as employment creation and less inequality. The weaknesses and advances of the Left in response to the current context are critically assessed in this volume.
By applying a rigorous Marxist (and neo-Marxist) political-economic analysis of the contemporary capitalist crisis and the Left’s response to it, this volume confronts some of the inherited weaknesses of Marxist theoretical approaches to capitalist crises. The first weakness, according to Lilley (2012: 44), can be referred to as the ‘vanguardist’ dyad of structural determinism, on the one side, and voluntarism on the other.1 Structural-determinist approaches give primacy to the ‘laws of history’ and the limits of the capitalist system (or the internal weight of its own contradictions). Voluntarist approaches tend to emphasise greater suffering and worsening conditions, and ultimately argue that state repression will reveal the essence of the capitalist crisis. Put differently, neither approach takes account of the connection between capitalist crisis and the challenging task of building democratic, mass-movement-driven politics. The second weakness is how conceptions of capitalist crisis are inserted into struggle. Both of these approaches propagandise capitalist crisis to such an extent that theoretical analysis is used as an instrument to affirm that history is on the side of the working class and therefore an automatic awakening of consciousness is meant to follow. Yet nowhere has this panned out in actual history or struggle.
Furthermore, both of these approaches tend to guide practice in particular ways. A structuralist approach tends to abstain from struggle, whereas a voluntarist approach arrogantly proclaims its need to make history now by accelerating collapse or crisis through adventurist intervention.
In this volume the authors seek to confront these weaknesses of orthodox vanguardist Marxist theory and its practical political conclusions. In the process, the book seeks to go beyond twentieth-century communist and social-democratic understandings of the crisis. Instead, the volume raises democratic Marxist perspectives on the crisis, and looks at contemporary left agency and the need for transformative politics, rather than vanguardist revolutionary or reformist left politics. This volume therefore takes forward themes that are referred to but not fully elaborated in Volume 1 in this series, titled Marxisms in the 21st Century. The first volume provided a research agenda
