© 2014 Kim Moody
Published in 2014 by
Haymarket Books
P.O. Box 180165
Chicago, IL 60618
773-583-7884
www.haymarketbooks.org
ISBN: 978-1-60846-458-6
Trade distribution:
In the US, Consortium Book Sales and Distribution, www.cbsd.com
In the UK, Turnaround Publisher Services, www.turnaround-uk.com
In Canada, Publishers Group Canada, www.pgcbooks.ca
In Australia, Palgrave Macmillan, www.palgravemacmillan.com.au
All other countries, Publishers Group Worldwide, www.pgw.com
Special discounts are available for bulk purchases by organizations and institutions. Please contact Haymarket Books for more information at 773-583-7884 or [email protected].
Cover design by Josh On. Cover image of protesters in the rotunda of the state Capitol in Madison, Wisconsin, against the state budget and anti-union legislation proposed by Republican Governor Scott Walker. Photo by Brian Kersey, UPI.
This book was published with the generous support of Lannan Foundation.
Library of Congress CIP data is available.
List of Tables
Table 1.1 Race and Gender Composition of US Unions in 2012 by Number and Percentage 14
Table 7.1 Number of Workers in Won NLRB Representation Elections, Ratio of 8a ULPs to Elections, and Union Win Rates, 1950s–2000s 199
Table 8.1 Private-Sector Union Membership 207
Table 8.2 Organizing Efforts by Type 211
Table 8.3 Union Density by Industry and Occupation, 2003–2007 216
Table 8.4 Unions with Net Gains, 2000–2007 217
Table 9.1 Average Annual Private-Sector Union Membership, Density, Strikes, and Duration in the 1970s and 2000s 230
Table 9.2 Strike Threats, Strikes, Threats of Replacements, and Use of Replacements in Collective Bargaining, 1996, 1999, and 2003 234
Table 10.1 Climate for Patient Care and Inclination to Vote for a Union 260
Table 10.2 Distribution of NLRB Elections, Hospitals (622) 2010, by Union and Region 266
Table E.1 Average Annual Negotiated Wage Increase, CPI-W, and Strikes 2006–2012 305
Table E.2 Real Employment Costs (Total Compensation) and Productivity Indices, Nonfinancial Private Sector, 2006–2012 306
Introduction
This collection focuses above all on the organized working class in the United States. While I have written much about global capitalism and labor internationalism in the past, these essays attempt to analyze the problems and responses in the labor movement with which I am most familiar. Some of these were written for political publications or organizations. Several of the more recent essays are in academic form, for which I apologize to the reader. Whatever the format of the original publication of the essays in this collection, my objective has always been the same: to explore how the existing organs of class struggle can be improved, and in that process how can socialists connect their ideas and strategies to the living working class.
The great problem facing socialists for many decades in the United States, and perhaps to a lesser degree elsewhere, has been the separation of socialist ideas and organization from the day-to-day life of those who, at least in the Marxist view, are the necessary carriers of socialist revolution and human liberation. Outsider propaganda has been a manifest failure. Like all social movements, a socialist movement based in the working class will require human agency and direct day-to-day contact. There are, of course, more socialists of various kinds active in US unions today than one might imagine from the behavior of most union leaders, and this book, it is hoped, will help them by providing analysis and ideas about perspectives and strategies. But since the number of socialists in unions is limited and organizationally fragmented, this collection is also meant to encourage activists from the newer movements confronting capitalism in one way or another—occupying, fighting home foreclosures, or breaking down barriers to society’s excluded and oppressed—to take a critical look at the labor movement for the potential allies within.
To some, the emphasis on unions and unionized workers will seem strange or even pointless. Aren’t America’s labor unions continuing their long journey to oblivion? Haven’t they lost millions of members to capital’s relentless attacks on working-class people of all races and ethnicities, as several of the essays in this collection show? Of course they have.Yet, with nearly fifteen million members, unions remain the largest and most diverse working-class organizations in the United States. As the workforce has changed in the last several decades, so has organized labor. Women now compose 46 percent of all union members, while African Americans, Latinos, and Asians account for 30 percent, percentages that closely reflect the US population.1 Union organization remains arguably the potentially most powerful way in which working-class resistance expresses itself within the problematic political culture of America.
Whether in growth or crisis, capital—and the “one percent” who most embody it—has undermined and destroyed the lives of millions the world around. Resistance is now evident across the globe and there is no reason to doubt that sooner or later, in one form or another, it will sweep the shores of the United States. We can see this resistance in recent uprisings from Egypt to Europe. It is in such resistance that people are transformed, their minds opened, and new possibilities created. It is there, I believe, that socialists need to be.
“The Union” Isn’t Always What It Seems
Commentators, journalists, academics, socialists, and even this writer frequently refer to “the union” as though it were one thing. But what is this “thing” we call “the union”? As Sheila Cohen has argued, the union is, in fact, at least two contradictory things: the union as institution and the union as movement or membership.2 The leadership is bound to protect the institution, a role that breeds caution. Furthermore, the leadership, in its role as negotiator, is placed in a position somewhere between the employers and the union’s members, far removed from the workplace and the daily experience of the members. At the same time, “the union” is a social movement meant to reflect the needs and aspirations of the membership. The need to fight for these and, indeed, the existence of unions in the first place are rooted in the contradictions of the capital-labor relationship, that is, in the reality of exploitation that originates in the workplace and in capital’s constant push for increased relative surplus value. Thus, in good times and bad, there is a tension between the union as institution and as movement. This is not to say that all union officials are the same or even that all members are always ahead of their leaders. Sometimes the leaders are to the “left” of their
