Email “Messages”
Inbox [12/70]
To: Dr. Crane [eaglechristianchurch.com]
Subject: Was Jesus Really Dead Three Days?
---Original Message---
If Jesus was crucified on Friday, how could he have been in the grave three days and nights?
Reply:
Some scholars do believe that Jesus was in the grave for three full days and nights (72 hours). Those who hold to this suggest that he was crucified either on Wednesday or Thursday. In support of their view they posit that Passover was not a fixed day (Friday), but that it floated from year to year. They then point out that the Bible does not record any activity for Jesus on Wednesday—allowing them to move the crucifixion up accordingly.
Most biblical scholars, however, believe that Jesus was crucified on Friday and acknowledge that Jesus was only in the tomb for parts of three days—pointing out that the phrase “on the third day” (Matthew 16:21; 17:23; 20:19; 26:61) can legitimately be understood to mean “within three days,” rather than 72 hours. It is certainly used this way elsewhere (cf. Esther 4:16).
This second view certainly fits best within the chronological order of events given by the gospel writers (see Mark 14:1ff) as well as the fact that Jesus died on Passover day (Friday) to fulfill the conditions of being our Passover Lamb (1 Corinthians 5:7; Leviticus 23:5–15).
Email “Messages”
Inbox [13/70]
To: Dr. Crane [eaglechristianchurch.com]
Subject: Did Jesus Really Preach in Hell?
---Original Message---
Did Jesus really go to the depths of hell to preach the gospel to spirits who were held captive there?
Reply:
The question you ask finds its basis in 1 Peter 3:19–20. The great theologian, Martin Luther, said that this section of Scripture was: “. . . a more obscure passage perhaps than any other in the New Testament,” and that he did not know “for a certainty just what Peter means.”
No one can come to such a passage with an air of certainty, but that does not mean we cannot wrestle with it. To attempt to understand this passage, a person must ask and answer a number of questions. When did Jesus go and preach? To whom did Jesus preach? What was the message Jesus preached, and what does this illustration of baptism and Noah mean?
There are many opinions, and not all scholars agree. I will give you the most common interpretations, and then my opinion (you are certainly free to disagree).
When did Jesus go and preach? (3:18–19)
Jesus is said to have preached to “spirits in prison.” When did this happen? There are three answers given.
1. Some say this happened in the O. T. before Jesus came to earth. Christ’s spirit was in Noah as Noah preached to those imprisoned by sin (but now in hell). Through the preaching of Noah, the spirit of Christ was revealed, but those who heard him preach rejected his message, so they are now in spiritual prison. This is referring back to Genesis, and it was not Christ preaching, but Christ’s spirit being preached by Noah.
2. A second view (the most popular) holds that between his death and resurrection, Christ preached to those people who had previously died without hearing the gospel message. During the period when Jesus was in the grave, his spirit went and preached to souls in Hades, giving them an opportunity to hear the gospel.
3. My personal opinion is that this is referring to a post-resurrection appearance. I actually think that the text demands this view. Look at verse 18 a little closer. Christ was put to death in the body but made alive by the Spirit. In Greek this is a contrasting clause. On the one hand—he died. On the other hand—he was made alive. Literally, “On the one hand put to death in the flesh, on the other hand made alive in the spirit. At which time . . .” It is a post resurrection that is in view.
To whom did Jesus preach? (3:19)
Again there are three basic views.
1. The first view holds that Noah preached to men, in the spirit of Christ, who because they were disobedient, are now in prison waiting the resurrection.
2. The second view (most popular) is that during the time in the tomb, Jesus went and preached to “the souls of men” who were disobedient in the Old Testament, giving them the opportunity to hear the gospel.
3. Again, I’ve got to disagree with both these views. Both these views assume the word “spirit” here refers to the spirit of men. When the word “spirit” is used in Scripture, it is seldom used of men unless it is qualified by the phrase “the spirit of man.” The word “soul” is usually used. Not only that, but again in this passage we find a contrast between verse 19, “the spirits who were disobedient, in prison” and that of verse 22, “those angels, authorities and powers who are in submission to him.” These are not the spirits of men, but fallen angels and demonic forces that oppose Christ.
Which brings us to a third, and probably the most important question.
What did Jesus preach?
This is the easiest question to answer. But even here we have two views.
1. The first view (most popular) holds that Christ preached salvation.
2. But the word here translated “preach” is not euangelion, to preach the gospel. It is actually the word karrusso which means to “proclaim” or “announce.” The message proclaimed is the message of victory and triumph—Jesus is alive and well. He has demonstrated victory, power over death. He has triumphed and is proclaiming that victory with finality. The battle has been fought; the victory has been secured.
And notice our text again. These difficult portions are sandwiched between a section that is easily understood. “For Christ died for sins once for all, the righteous for the unrighteous, to bring you to God. He was put to death in the body, but made alive by the Spirit . . . (he) has gone into heaven and is at God’s right hand—with angels, authorities and powers in submission to him.”
Christ died . . . once for all. The righteous for the unrighteous. To bring you to God. He was put to death . . . but is now alive. Everything is in submission to him. What hope this would have brought to first century Christians, who at times thought they were losing the battle. It’s the message of hope, and life, and victory; and this victory was announced by Christ at his resurrection to all spiritual forces who opposed him. God dealt with sin in the past by destroying people with the flood, but in these times, he dealt sin a death blow through the resurrection of Jesus Christ. The message being proclaimed here is victory over death, victory over sin, and victory over our spiritual enemies.
Which brings us to the last question we need to answer.
What does the illustration of baptism mean? (3:21)
Again there are two words I’d like to point out to you.
The word “symbolizes” is the word anti-topos. It’s a figure, an example, a comparison. And Peter makes sure
