British force did not ascertain Montgomery’s death until the next day. The British sent out a party to survey the American dead at that time. With the cooperation of a captured Continental officer, the detail found and identified Montgomery’s body where he fell the day before. About three feet of accumulated snow partially obscured the solidly frozen remains, but his raised arm remained visible above the snow. The party also discovered his sword lying beside the body. Violent death had reduced this imposing figure of a military leader in life—tall, straight, lean, vibrant—to a grotesque, distorted form with knees drawn up toward the head.8
The British were almost as regretful of Montgomery’s death as the Americans. Gov. Guy Carleton and other British officers who defended Quebec against Montgomery’s attack had served with him earlier during the Seven Years’ War. Montgomery saw duty in the British army from 1756 to 1773, rising to the rank of captain before he sold his commission. He subsequently settled in New York, married Janet Livingston of the prominent Robert R. Livingston, Sr., family, and in 1775 took up arms against his former country when offered a brigadier general’s commission in the Continental army. Even though Montgomery changed allegiances, his former military acquaintances still respected his personal character and military leadership ability.9 Guy Carleton ordered Montgomery’s body decently buried within Quebec.10
Soon after his death, Edmund Burke, an opposition statesman, delivered an eloquent and moving eulogy of Montgomery in the British Parliament. Prime Minister Lord Frederick North, however, became agitated by this discourse and replied: “I cannot join in lamenting the death of Montgomery as a public loss. A curse on his virtues! They’ve undone this country. He was brave, he was noble, he was humane, he was generous: but still he was only a brave, able, humane, and generous rebel.” Charles James Fox, another liberal member of Parliament, retorted, “The term of rebel is no certain mark of disgrace. The great asserters of liberty, the saviors of their country, the benefactors of mankind in all ages, have all been called rebels.”11
Americans were even more profuse in their praise of the fallen general. Benedict Arnold served under Montgomery at Quebec. Arnold, who could be a harsh critic, paid his superior officer sincere tribute and maintained that had not Montgomery “received the fatal shot . . . the town would have been ours.”12 Gen. Philip Schuyler, Montgomery’s commanding officer during the Canadian operation, grieved: “My amiable and gallant General Montgomery is no more. . . . My feelings on this unhappy occasion are too poignant to admit of expression. May Heaven avert any further evils.”13
Mourning Montgomery’s untimely death was not confined to those closely associated with him. He was the first American general officer killed in the War for American Independence. Joseph Warren, whom the Continental Congress had appointed major general but had not yet confirmed his commission, died at Bunker Hill six months earlier. Montgomery’s heroic deed eclipsed that of Warren, and the Americans quickly elevated him to martyrdom in their struggle for independence. During the critical time when the colonists debated the issue of armed revolt, revolutionary Americans touted Montgomery’s sacrifice to evoke patriotic spirit toward continuing the war.
In 1776, a patriot pamphlet appeared in Philadelphia under the title A Dialogue between the Ghost of General Montgomery and an American Delegate in a Wood Near Philadelphia. This work is generally attributed to Thomas Paine, revolutionary America’s most influential pamphleteer.14 In 1777, Hugh Henry Brackenridge published a heroic tragedy, The Death of General Montgomery. It was a dramatic poem clearly intended to arouse colonial sentiments against the British.15
The hapless fortune of the day is sunk!
Montgomery slain, and wither’d every hope!
Mysterious Providence, thy ways are just,
And we submit in deep humility.
But O let fire or pestilence from Heaven,
Avenge the butchery; let Englishmen,
The cause and agents in this horrid war,
In tenfold amplitude, meet gloomy death.16
The Continental Congress played an important role in advancing Montgomery’s contribution to the patriot cause. After learning of the general’s death, Congress issued a proclamation stating “their grateful remembrance, respect, and high veneration; and desiring to transmit to future ages a truly worthy example of patriotism, conduct, boldness of enterprise, insuperable perseverance, and contempt of danger and death.”17
On January 22, 1776, Congress appointed a committee, which included Benjamin Franklin, to “consider a proper method of paying a just tribute of gratitude to the memory of General Montgomery.”18 Three days later, the committee recommended that a memorial be obtained from Paris, “with an inscription, sacred to his [Montgomery’s] memory, and expressive of his amiable character and heroick achievements.”19 Congress approved the recommendation, and Benjamin Franklin made the necessary arrangements for a stone marker to be made. In the following year, Franklin described the completed monument as “plain, but elegant, being done by one of the best artists in Paris.”20
Finding a suitable location for the shrine was delayed until after the war. Eventually, New York City accepted the honor of receiving the nation’s approbation to the American patriot. In 1787, with proper ceremony, authorities erected the marker at St. Paul’s Church. It remains today as the first monument dedicated by the government to an American revolutionary hero. The memorial bears the following original inscription:
This Monument
is erected
By order of Congress, 25th January, 1776
To transmit to posterity
A Grateful Remembrance
of the
Patriotism, Conduct, Enterprize and Perseverance
of
Major General Richard Montgomery
who after a series of successes
Amidst the most discouraging difficulties,
Fell in the attack on Quebec,
31st December, 1775. Aged 37 years.21
In 1818, American officials reclaimed Montgomery’s remains from Quebec and reinterred them appropriately within his chosen country. The final resting place was located next to the original monument at St. Paul’s Church.
The Continental Congress also used Montgomery’s death as a justification for expanding state commitments to the revolutionary effort. On September 24, 1776, Congress sent resolves to the states, raising quotas and increasing enlistment time for troops to be provided for the Continental army. In a letter enclosed with the resolves, John Hancock stated: “The fall of the late Genl. Montgomery before Quebec is undoubtedly to be ascribed to the limited time for which the troops were engaged; whose impatience to return home compelled him to make the attack contrary to the conviction of his own judgment. This fact alone furnishes a striking argument of the danger and impropriety of sending troops into the field under any restrictions as to the time of their enlistment. The noblest enterprize may be left unfinished by troops in such a predicament, or abandoned at the very moment success must have crowned the attempt.”22
It is somewhat ironic that Richard Montgomery, who was so well regarded by his contemporaries and whose death was so highly instrumental in forming general opinion during the Revolution, should now occupy such an obscure place in the historiography
