Taken one by one, the words were all familiar—taken as a whole, they made no sense at all. She let the book slip unheeded from her mind and stared at Dr. Andrews in bewilderment.
“Try saying it in a different way.”
“You sound like a school teacher humoring a stupid child.” And then, because of the habit of obedience was strong, “I guess he meant that tails didn’t grow an inch at a time, the way the dog’s got cut off, but all at once ... like a fish being born with legs as well as fins, or a baby saber-tooth showing up among tigers with regular teeth, or one ape in a tribe discovering he could swing down out of the treetops and stand erect and walk alone.”
He echoed her last words. “And walk alone....” A premonitory chill traced its icy way down Lucilla’s backbone. For a second she stood on gray moss, under a gray sky, in the midst of a gray silence. “He not only could walk alone, he had to. Do you remember what your book said?”
“Only the fittest survive,̶#8221; Lucilla said numbly. “Because they have to fight the climate ... and their natural enemies ... and their own kind.” She swung her feet to the floor and pushed herself into a sitting position. “I’m not a ... a mutation. I’m not, I’m not, I’m NOT, and you can’t say I am, because I won’t listen!”
“I didn’t say you were.” There was the barest hint of emphasis on the first word. Lucilla was almost certain she heard a whisper of laughter, but he met her gaze blandly, his expression completely serious.
“Don’t you dare laugh!” she said, nonetheless. “There’s nothing funny about ... about....”
“About being able to read people’s minds,” Dr Andrews said helpfully. “You’d much rather have me offer some other explanation for the occurrences that bother you so—is that it?”
“I guess so. Yes, it is. A brain tumor. Or schizophrenia. Or anything at all that could maybe be cured, so I could marry Paul and have children and be like everybody else. Like you.” She looked past him to the picture on his desk. “It’s easy for you to talk.”
He ignored the last statement. “Why can’t you get married, anyway?”
“You’ve already said why. Because Paul would hate me—everybody would hate me—if they knew I was different.”
“How would they know? It doesn’t show. Now if you had three legs, or a long bushy tail, or outsized teeth....”
Lucilla smiled involuntarily, and then was furious at herself for doing so and at Dr Andrews for provoking her into it. “This whole thing is utterly asinine, anyhow. Here we are, talking as if I might really be a mutant, and you know perfectly well that I’m not.”
“Do I? You made the diagnosis, Lucilla, and you’ve given me some mighty potent reasons for believing it ... can you give me equally good reasons for doubting that you’re a telepath?”
*
The peremptory demand left Lucilla speechless for a moment. She groped blindly for an answer, then almost laughed aloud as she found it.
“But of course. I almost missed it, even after you practically drew me a diagram. If I could read minds, just as soon as anybody found it out, he’d be afraid of me, or hate me, like the book said, and you said, too. If you believed it, you’d do something like having me locked up in a hospital, maybe, instead of....”
“Instead of what, Lucilla?”
“Instead of being patient, and nice, and helping me see how silly I’ve been.” She reached out impulsively to touch his hand, then withdrew her own, feeling somewhat foolish when he made no move to respond. Her relief was too great, however, to be contained in silence. “Way back the first time I came in, almost, you said that before we finished therapy, you’d know me better than I knew myself. I didn’t believe you—maybe I didn’t want to—but I begin to think you were right. Lot of times, lately, you’ve answered a question before I even asked it. Sometimes you haven’t even bothered to answer—you’ve just sat there in your big brown chair and I’ve lain here on the couch, and we’ve gone through something together without using words at all....” She had started out almost gaily, the words spilling over each other in their rush to be said, but bit by bit she slowed down, then faltered to a stop. After she had stopped talking altogether, she could still hear her last few phrases, repeated over and over, like an echo that refused to die. (Answered ... before I even asked ... without using words at all ... without using words....)
She could almost taste the terror that clogged her throat and dried her lips. “You do believe it. And you could have me locked up. Only ... only....” Fragments of thought, splinters of words, and droplets of silence spun into a kaleidoscopic jumble, shifted infinitesimally, and fell into an incredible new pattern. Understanding displaced terror and was, in turn, displaced by indignation. She stared accusingly at her interrogator. “But you look just like ... just like anybody.”
“You expected perhaps three legs or a long bushy tail or teeth like that textbook tiger?”
“And you’re a psychiatrist!”
“What else? Would you have talked to me like this across a grocery counter, Lucilla? Or listened to me, if I’d been driving a bus or filling a prescription? Would I have found the others in a bowling alley or a business office?”
“Then there are ... others?” She let out her breath on a long sigh involuntarily glancing again at the framed picture. “Only I love Paul, and he isn’t ... he can’t....”
“Nor can Carol.” His eyes were steady on hers, yet she felt as if he were looking through and beyond her. For no reason at all, she strained her ears for the sound of footsteps or the summons of a voice. “Where do you suppose the second little blob of protoplasm with legs came from?” Dr. Andrews asked. “And the third? If that ape who found he could stand erect had walked lonesomely off into the sunset like a second-rate actor on a late, late show, where do you suppose you’d be today?”
He broke off abruptly and watched with Lucilla as the office door edged open. The small girl who inched her way around it wore blue jeans and a pony tail rather than an organdy frock and curls, but her pixie smile matched that of the girl in the photograph Lucilla had glanced at again and again.
“You wanted me, Daddy?” she asked, but she looked toward Lucilla.
“I thought you’d like to meet someone with the same nickname as yours,” Dr. Andrews said, rising to greet her. “Lucky, meet Lucky.”
“Hello,” the child said, then her smile widened. “Hello!” (But I don’t have to say it, do I? I can talk to you just the way I talk to Daddy and Uncle Whitney and Big Bill).
“Hello yourself,” said Lucilla. This time when the corners of her mouth began to tick upward, she made no attempt to stop them. (Of course you can, darling. And I can answer you the same way, and you’ll hear me.)
Dr. Andrews reached for the open pack of cigarettes on his deck. (Is this strictly a private conversation, girls, or can I get in on it, too?)
(It’s unpolite to interrupt, Daddy.)
(He’s not exactly interrupting—it was his conversation to begin with!)
Dr. Andrews’ receptionist paused briefly beside the still-open office door. None of them heard either her gentle rap or the soft click of
