Tech nology and Military History
By Hans Henrik Appel, Dr, the Association of Danish Museums
The great military and Renaissance historian, the late Joh n R. Hale, claimed the trace italienne fortifications to be the most distinct feature in Renaissance architecture. The new, strictly regular town planning was driven by the demands of the new military architecture and the trace italienne was probably the most widespread architectural style in sixteenth and seventeenth century Europe. Historians have interpreted this as proof of its revolutionary or decisive impact on Early Modern warfare; and along the same lines, the trace italienne fortifications have been attributed a pivotal role in the development of huge, permanent armies – and the building of powerful states to sustain them.
This article examines some of the main positions (and often mentioned events in this debate, such as the fall of Constantinople in 1453 and the French conquest of Italy in 1494), arguing that although the trace italienne fortifications and increased firepower were important elements in Early Modern Warfare, it is misleading to emphasize them as decisive. Close examinations of campaigns, sieges etc. more often than not point to “the friction of war” (such as plagues, famine, weather, discipline) as playing just as important a role as tech nology and strategy. Furthermore, the development of tech nology might not be as straightforward and linear as one might tend to believe.
Attempts to define a single tech nological or tactical innovation as decisive illustrate that military history, for many years, has been seen as a practical science from which lessons on successful warfare for future military men can – and ought to – be learned. It is, therefore, important to have a closer look at modern, specialized literature on military tech nology such as the work of DeVries, Guilmartin, Hall, Pepper, Smith and others, who undermine some of the general assumptions on “winning tech nology” that are repeated in many broader presentations of Renaissance military history.
LITTERATUR
Adams, Simon: “Tactics or Politics? ‘The Military Revolution’ and the Hapsburg Hegemony, 1525-1648”, Clifford J. Rogers (ed.): The Military Revolution Debate, 1995, s. 253-272.
Arnold, Thomas: “Fortifications and the Military Revolution: The Gonzaga Experience, 1530-1630”, Clifford J. Rogers (ed.): The Military Revolution Debate, 1995, s. 201-226.
Ayton, Andrew & J.L. Price (eds.): The Medieval Military Revolution. State, Society and Military Change in Medieval Modern Europe, London 1998.
Bengedans, Johannes: Krigskunst og kanoner: Johannes Bengedans’ bøssemester- og krigsbog. Udg. Hans Blosen & Rikke Agnete Olsen, Aarhus 2006.
Black, Jeremy: “A Military Revolution? A 1660-1792 Perspective”, Clifford J. Rogers (ed.): The Military Revolution Debate, 1995, s. 95-116.
Bradbury, Jim: The Medieval Siege, Woodbridge 1992.
Corfis, Ivy A. & Michael Wolfe (eds.): The medieval city under siege, Rochester, New York 1995.
Downing, Brian M.: The Military Revolution and Political Change, Columbia 1992.
DeVries, Kelly: “The Impact of Gunpowder Weaponry on Siege Warfare in the Hundred Years War”, Ivy A. Corfis & Michael Wolfe (eds.): The medieval city under siege, 1995, s. 227-244.
DeVries, Kelly: “Gunpowder and Early Gunpowder Weapons”, Brenda Buchanan (ed.): Gunpowder: The History of an International Tech nology. Bath 1996, s. 121-135. [Cit.: DeVries 1996a].
DeVries, Kelly: “Gunpowder Weapons at the Siege of Constantinople, 1453”, Yaacov Lev (ed.): War, Army and Society In the Eastern Mediterranean 7th-16th Centuries, Leiden 1996, s. 343-362. [Cit.: DeVries 1996b].
DeVries, Kelly: “Catapults are not Atomic Bombs: Towards a Redefinition of ‘Effeciveness’ in Premodern Military Tech nology”, War in History 4, 1997, s. 454-470. [Cit.: DeVries 1997a].
DeVries, Kelly: “The Tech nology of Gunpowder Weaponry in Western Europe during the Hundred Years War”, XXII. Kongress der Internationalen Kommission für Militärgeschiche Acta 22: Von Crécy bis Mohács Kriegswesen im späten Mittelalter, Wien 1997, s. 285-298. [Cit.: DeVries 1997b].
DeVries, Kelly: “Gunpowder Weaponry and the Rise of the Early Modern State”, War in His tory 5, 1998, s. 127-145.
DeVries, Kelly: Guns and Men in Medieval Europe 1200-1500, Aldershot 2002.
Duffy, Christopher: Siege Warfare. The Fortress in the Early Modern World 1494-1660, London 1976.
Eltis, David: The Military Revolution in Sixteenth Century Europe. London 1998.
Ffoulkes, Charles J.: The Gun-Founders of England, Cambridge 1937.
Frost, Robert I.: The Northern Wars: War, State and Society in Northeastern Europe, 1558-1721, Harlow 2000.
Guilmartin, J.F.: Gunpowder and Galleys, 2. ed., London 2003.
Hale, Joh n R.: Renaissance War Studies, London 1983.
Hall, Bert S.: “The Changing Face of Siege Warfare”, Ivy A. Corfis & Michael Wolfe (eds.) 1995, s. 257-275.
Hall, Bert S.: Weapons and Warfare in Renaissance Europe, Baltimore/London 1997.
Hogg, Ian V.: Fortress. A History of Military Defence, London 1975.
Hughes, Quentin: Military Architecture. The Art of Defence from Earliest Times to the Atlantic Wall, Liphook 1974.
Huizinga, Johan: “The problem of the Renaissance”, 1920, Johan Huizinga: Men and ideas: History, the Middle Ages, the Renaissance: Essays, New York 1960, s. 243-287.
Lynn, Joh n A.: “The trace italienne and the Growth of Armies: The French Case”, Clifford J. Rogers (ed.): The Military Revolution Debate, 1995, s. 169-200.
Mortensen, Michael: Dansk artilleri indtil 1600, København 1999.
Parker, Geoffrey: The Military Revolution. Military innovation and the rise of the West 1500-1800, Cambridge 1988.
Parker, Geoffrey: “The ‘Military Revolution, 1560-1660’ – A Myth?” (1976), Clifford J. Rogers (ed.): The Military Revolution Debate, 1995, s. 37-54. [Cit.: Parker 1976/1995].
Parker, Geoffrey: “In Defense of The Military Revolution”, Clifford J. Rogers (ed.): The Military Revolution Debate, 1995, s. 337-365. [Cit.: Parker 1995].
Pepper, Simon: “Castles and cannon in the Naples campaign of 1494-95”, David Abulafia (ed.): The French Descent into Renaissance Italy 1494-95: Antecedents and Effects, Brookfield 1995, s. 263-281.
Pepper, Simon & Nicholas Adams: Firearms & Fortifications. Military Architecture and Siege Warfare in Sixteenth Century Siena, Chicago 1986.
Roberts, Michael: “The Military Revolution, 1560-1660”, Clifford J. Rogers (ed.): The Military Revolution Debate, 1995, s. 13-36.
Rogers, Clifford J. (ed.): The Military Revolution Debate: Readings on the Military Transformation of Early Modern Europe, Boulder/San Francisco/Oxford 1995.
Rogers, Clifford J.: “The Military Revolutions of the Hundred Years
